Saturday, May 16, 2009

The Point About Inflection Points

My unsystematic survey of the mass media tells me that the term “inflection point” has entered the popular lexicon in the last week or two, probably because of the discussion of whether a reversal in the second derivative of changes in GDP or unemployment constitutes a “green shoot”. Now we have usages like this:

In a testy exchange with reporters, Mr. Obama’s press secretary, Robert Gibbs, argued that on Monday, before the decisions were announced, he was being asked why the president insisted on being “so opposite of George Bush in all these questions, and on Friday I’m answering questions about why are we so much like George Bush on all these questions.”

“I’ll let you guys discern what inflection point, what period of day, that all changed,” Mr. Gibbs continued.


If you remember your calculus, you’ll probably think, as I did, this guy is confusing first and second derivatives. But the larger point, I suspect, is that we are going through a long period in which, as more of the population acquires basic technical training, math and science language is going to enter the general discourse. This means that people without this training will be using the tech-talk too, and often getting it wrong. The division of society between people who have these skills and those who don’t will become more obvious. It becomes another form of “distinction”, in Bourdieu’s sense.

What does this have to do with the issue of military commissions and Guantanamo detainees? Nothing – it’s orthogonal.

3 comments:

rosserjb@jmu.edu said...

Peter,

Didn't you know? An inflection point is one of those places where if you pinch somebody, they will confess to all their potentially terroristic activities and impulses. Simple.

Juan said...

Corn for the day: Soon we will all be inflected...

W. Buiter, though, took Trichet's use of the term seriously:

Unlike the gormless arts students, limp-minded lawyers and woolly social scientists that dominate British and American economic policy making, President Trichet actually knows and understands mathematics. An inflection point is not a turning point.Inflection Points and Turning Points...

kevin quinn said...

More to wring my hands about. I've just about given up the battle against the misuse of "begs the question." And now this!